/ Dental Implants

Who Should Place Your Dental Implant? Dentist vs Specialist

A 2017 review found specialist status didn't change implant failure (OR 1.24), but surgeons with under 50 implants had higher odds (OR 2.18). How to choose.

Two dentists in masks examine a dental X ray on a screen beside a patient in a dental chair.

In 2017, a systematic review of surgeon experience and implant survival reported two findings that don’t sit easily together. When experience was defined as being a specialist, it didn’t significantly change implant failure (odds ratio 1.24, 95% CI 0.62 to 2.48). When it was defined as having placed more than 50 implants, it did (odds ratio 2.18, 95% CI 1.40 to 3.39) (Sendyk et al., International Journal of Prosthodontics, 2017).

So does the title on the door matter, or the number of cases behind it? This guide explains who can place implants in Dubai, what the different professionals do, what the evidence says about specialists and experience, and which questions get a useful answer. It builds on, and doesn’t repeat, our checklist on DHA licenses and the Implantology Privilege.

Key Takeaways A 2017 meta-analysis found specialist status didn’t significantly change implant failure (OR 1.24), but surgeons who’d placed fewer implants had about twice the odds (OR 2.18 in two studies using a 50-implant cut-off). The evidence is retrospective and limited. Ask how many implants the clinician has placed and how complications are handled, not only what the title is.

Is “Implantologist” a Specialty?

Not in the sense most patients assume. In Dubai, the credential in regulatory use is the DHA Implantology Privilege, an additional authorisation for licensed general dentists and dental specialists, requiring supervised training and documented cases (Dubai Health Authority, Dental Implantology Privilege Requirements circular, 2021, as summarised in our implant dentist checklist). I haven’t found “implantologist” defined as a separate specialty category in the DHA material used for this guide, so treat it as a descriptive term, not a protected title.

That has a practical consequence. Two people who both call themselves implantologists can have very different training and caseloads. The reliable checks are whether the clinician holds the privilege (verifiable on the DHA registry), what their formal training is, and how many cases they’ve done. Dr. Shreya Rajkumar holds the DHA Implantology Privilege, as stated in our earlier checklist; I’m not quoting a caseload figure here because I don’t have a verified one to give.

What Do the Different Professionals Do?

The labels below are general descriptions of the professions, not DHA definitions, so treat them as Tier 4 background.

Who Does What in Implant Treatment Four columns. General dentist with the DHA Implantology Privilege: licensed dentist authorised to place implants, usually straightforward cases. Periodontist: specialist in gums and the bone that supports teeth. Oral or maxillofacial surgeon: specialist in surgery of the jaws and mouth, often complex or grafting cases. Prosthodontist: specialist in designing and fitting replacement teeth and crowns. Per DHA circular as summarised on this site, advanced procedures such as sinus lifts and major bone grafting are restricted to oral surgeons, maxillofacial surgeons and periodontists. Role descriptions are general teaching. General dentist + privilege Licensed and authorised to place implants Often single-site, straightforward cases Periodontist Specialist in gums and the bone that supports teeth Gum disease, grafts, sinus lifts Oral or maxillofacial surgeon Specialist in surgery of the jaws and mouth Complex cases, major bone grafting Prosthodontist Specialist in designing and fitting replacement teeth and crowns Often plans the final tooth and bite Role descriptions are general teaching (Tier 4). Advanced-procedure limits per DHA circular, 2021.
Many implant cases involve more than one of these roles. A single-site case might involve one dentist; a complex case a team.

Under DHA’s scope-of-practice framework, as summarised in our earlier guide, advanced procedures such as sinus lifts and major bone grafting are restricted to oral surgeons, oral and maxillofacial surgeons and periodontists. A general dentist with the privilege can place straightforward single-site implants but not those. If your case needs grafting, that is the point at which a specialist or a referral enters.

A dentist working on a patient's teeth in a dental clinic under bright lighting

Does a Specialist Title Mean Fewer Failures?

Not clearly. The 2017 review included 8 studies in its qualitative analysis and 6 in its quantitative synthesis. In four retrospective studies that defined experienced professionals as specialists, surgeon experience didn’t significantly affect implant failure (odds ratio 1.24, 95% CI 0.62 to 2.48, p = 0.54). In two retrospective studies that defined experienced surgeons as those who had placed more than 50 implants, experience did significantly affect failure (odds ratio 2.18, 95% CI 1.40 to 3.39, p = 0.0005) (Sendyk et al., International Journal of Prosthodontics, 2017).

Surgeon Experience and Implant Failure: Two Definitions Forest plot on a log scale from 0.5 to 4, with the line of no difference at 1. Specialist versus non-specialist: odds ratio 1.24, 95 percent confidence interval 0.62 to 2.48, crossing 1, not significant. Surgeons with 50 or fewer implants versus more than 50: odds ratio 2.18, interval 1.40 to 3.39, not crossing 1, significant. Retrospective studies. Source: Sendyk et al., International Journal of Prosthodontics, 2017. 0.5 1 (no difference) 2 4 Specialist status 4 studies 1.24 Over 50 implants placed 2 studies 2.18 Odds ratio of implant failure, less experienced vs experienced; bars show 95% confidence intervals (log scale).
When the bar crosses the dashed line, the difference could be chance. Only the implant-count definition cleared it.

[CITATION CAPSULE] A 2017 meta-analysis of surgeon experience and implant survival found no significant effect on implant failure when experience meant specialist status (OR 1.24, 95% CI 0.62 to 2.48), but a significant effect when it meant having placed more than 50 implants (OR 2.18, 95% CI 1.40 to 3.39). The authors called for standardised prospective studies (Sendyk et al., International Journal of Prosthodontics, 2017).

[UNIQUE INSIGHT] Specialty and experience are different variables. A specialist may be new to implants, and a general dentist may have placed hundreds. The title tells you about training in a field; the caseload tells you about practice with the procedure. Neither is a guarantee.

Read the limits. Only retrospective studies were included, the numbers were small, and the 50-implant analysis rested on two studies. The review also reports odds, not the share of patients affected. I’ve read the abstract, not the full paper, and I’ve taken the direction of the effect, with less experienced surgeons having higher odds, from the review’s stated comparison of inexperienced against experienced groups.

What Matters More Than the Title?

Several things, none of which show up on a business card. A scan-based plan is one: CBCT Scans for Implant Planning explains what a 3D scan shows that a 2D X-ray can’t. How the implant is placed is another; see Guided vs Freehand Implant Surgery. The third is what happens after placement: maintenance, early detection of problems and a plan for complications, covered in Dental Implant Problems.

Your own health also shifts the risk. Smoking, diabetes and untreated gum disease affect how implants do, which is why Diabetes, Smoking, and Dental Implant Risk Factors and Am I a Good Candidate for Dental Implants? come before any question of who does the surgery.

Which Case Needs Which Professional?

There’s no single rule, but a few patterns hold. A single missing tooth with good bone and healthy gums is commonly handled by a general dentist with the privilege. A case needing a sinus lift or substantial grafting falls under the specialist group restricted by the DHA framework. Full-arch treatment often involves a surgeon and a restorative dentist planning together. A patient with active gum disease needs it treated first.

The decision between an implant and other options is separate, and the answer may not involve an implant at all. Dental Bridges: Types, Survival Rates, and Bridge vs Implant compares the two with survival figures.

Which Questions Should You Ask?

Ask six things. Do you hold the DHA Implantology Privilege, and can I see it on the registry? How many implants of this type have you placed? Will you do the surgery and the crown, or will someone else, and how do you coordinate? What would make you refer me to a specialist? What are the most likely complications in my case and what’s the plan if one happens? And what does follow-up look like in the first year?

A longer list for a first consultation is in 7 Questions to Ask a Digital Implant Dentist. If you’re comparing clinics generally, How to Choose a Dentist in Dubai: 12 Checks Before You Book widens the checklist.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an implantologist a specialist?

The term isn’t a protected specialist title in the DHA material used here. What DHA recognises is the Implantology Privilege, held by licensed dentists and specialists who have met supervised training and case requirements. Ask for the privilege, training and caseload, not just the label.

Do specialists have better implant success?

Not clearly. A 2017 meta-analysis found no significant difference in implant failure between specialists and non-specialists (OR 1.24, 95% CI 0.62 to 2.48). The studies were retrospective and few, so the result is tentative, not proof of equality.

Does the number of implants a surgeon has placed matter?

It may. Two retrospective studies using a 50-implant cut-off found significantly higher odds of failure for less experienced surgeons (OR 2.18, 95% CI 1.40 to 3.39). It’s a small evidence base, so treat it as a reason to ask, not a pass mark.

When do I need an oral surgeon or periodontist?

When the case needs advanced work such as a sinus lift or major bone grafting, which DHA’s framework restricts to oral surgeons, maxillofacial surgeons and periodontists, as summarised in our earlier guide. A scan and consultation will show whether you need one.

Do you accept insurance for implants?

Implant cover varies widely between plans. Sofia Smile Clinic bills all insurers directly except Sukoon and GIG, which are handled as reimbursement, but whether a plan pays for implants is a separate question; see our insurance guide and ask the front desk.

Conclusion

The best evidence on who should place your implant says the specialist title alone didn’t significantly change failure rates, while a small number of studies linked limited experience to higher odds of failure. That points to caseload, planning and follow-up as the useful questions, with the title as one input among several.

If you’d like to see how this works in practice, you can book a consultation at Sofia Smile Clinic in Dubai Silicon Oasis. Dr. Shreya will review your scan, explain whether your case is straightforward or needs a referral, and answer the six questions above.


Sources

  • Sendyk DI, Chrcanovic BR, Albrektsson T, Wennerberg A, Zindel Deboni MC, Does Surgical Experience Influence Implant Survival Rate? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis, International Journal of Prosthodontics 2017, retrieved 2026-11-16 (Tier 1, 8 studies qualitative and 6 quantitative, retrospective cohorts, abstract-level data; direction of the odds ratios inferred from the abstract’s inexperienced-versus-experienced comparison)
  • Dubai Health Authority, Dental Implantology Privilege Requirements circular (CIR-2021-00000139), 2021, as read and cited in this site’s How to Choose an Implant Dentist in Dubai checklist (retrieved 2026-07-11 there; not re-read for this post) (Tier 1 via cross-reference)
  • Role descriptions of dental professionals are general teaching (Tier 4); Dr. Shreya Rajkumar’s DHA Implantology Privilege is stated in this site’s earlier checklist; Sofia Smile Clinic’s billing details are the clinic’s own statement (Tier 4)

Written by

Dr. Shreya Rajkumar

Dentist and implantologist, BDS · MSc (UK) · ICOI, with 8+ years placing dental implants and creating natural-looking smiles. She practises at Sofia Smile Clinic in Dubai Silicon Oasis and DentaZone in Gomti Nagar, Lucknow.

More about Dr. Shreya »